Housing & YIMBY · State Capacity · CA Ballot Measures

“Settler Colonialism”: The NIMBY Grift Exposed

California’s most powerful environmental justice group thinks your right to own a home is a colonial relic. They’re killing housing to prove it.

By Garry Tan · · 2 min read

Source: x.com

TL;DR

The California Environmental Justice Alliance calls market-rate housing “a vestige of settler colonialism” while blocking the homes middle-class families desperately need.

There’s a cottage industry of nonprofit groups in California whose entire business model depends on making your life more expensive. And the California Environmental Justice Alliance (CEJA)—described as the most important environmental justice organization in the state—just said the quiet part out loud.

@ArmandDoma
A
Armand Domalewski

The most important environmental justice organization in California, California Environmental Justice Alliance, thinks market rate housing is “a vestige of settler colonialism”

C
Cole Sandick🌹🇵🇸🇺🇦🇸🇩

It’s absurdly underreported how leftist politicians and voters are consistently more open YIMBYism than their ideological counterparts. Abundance libs have chosen to fixate on a marginal group of left-NIMBYs for the sake of bitter factionalism and it’s not good for their project. twitter.com/PEWilliams_/status/2007174191787954646

That’s right. The group that holds enormous sway over housing policy in California has officially declared that your ability to own a home—or even rent at market rates—is “a vestige of settler colonialism.” Their solution? “Decommodify housing and cultivate alternative ownership models.” Translation: kill market-rate housing and let nonprofits control everything.

4.6. Decommodify housing and cultivate alternative ownership models

The present system of private ownership is a vestige of settler colonialism that views housing as a commodity, rather than a human right. Housing should serve the needs of residents, not enrich Wall Street investors. Housing speculation and the expansion of corporate landlords have increased housing prices while preying on residents through rent gouging and predatory lending in the name of private profit.³⁰ Homeowners of col...
CEJA policy document calling private ownership “a vestige of settler colonialism.”·Source: x.com

This isn’t some fringe activist group posting on Tumblr. CEJA is the kind of organization that gets meetings with legislators, shapes environmental review processes, and extracts “community benefits” payments before allowing projects to proceed. When they oppose housing, projects die.

Tech founder Zach Weinberg—who built and sold companies to Google and Roche—put it bluntly:

He’s right. These nonprofits have figured out a perfect grift: oppose every project, demand money or concessions to drop opposition, then move on to the next one. All while California’s housing costs crush working families.

The irony is that this ideology doesn’t even represent most progressives. As one organizer pointed out, leftist voters are consistently more open to YIMBYism than their ideological counterparts. The left-NIMBY faction is marginal but extraordinarily loud—and they’ve captured the institutional infrastructure.

Meanwhile, the real victims are middle-class Californians who can’t afford a home because every market-rate project gets strangled by nonprofit opposition dressed up in activist language. If you want to help people at every income level, the answer is simple: build more housing and bring costs down for everyone. Not firehosing money to nonprofit grift.

Follow @garrytan for more.

Take Action

Share this exposé with Californians who deserve the truth

Comments (0)

Sign in to join the conversation.

Welcome to Garry's List.
We explain the world from a builder's lens.

Want to join the citizen's union? Apply in 5 minutes.