Democrats Are Eating Their Own Most Effective Voices

When Ezra Klein—one of the most prominent liberal journalists in America—gets called a “right-wing pundit” and “accessory to genocidal state violence,” the left has officially lost the plot.

Archived tweet

Calling the most reasonable center-left people "right wing pundits" is what... frankly a lot of people do. They do that to me all the time. When you see it, you should say something. That's not useful, and it will doom the Democratic party to a decade of failure. If you really want to fight Trump, Democrats must be competent instead of clout chasing extremists.

Garry Tan @garrytan January 31, 2026

Democrats must stop labeling every center-left voice as the enemy. This pattern of attacking our own most effective messengers is political suicide.

The Purity Spiral Swallows Its Own

Ezra Klein co-founded Vox, hosts one of the New York Times’ most popular podcasts, and has been a leading liberal voice for two decades. Yet on Bluesky, Jesse Singal found that the “near-unanimous belief” is that Klein is “a firmly right-wing pundit and frequent Trump apologist.”

The accusations get wilder. A campus group called Students for Justice in Palestine accused Klein of being “an apologist of white supremacist views and an accessory to genocidal state violence"—for speaking at an abundance conference with Derek Thompson and Governor Spencer Cox.

Archived tweet

I don't think @ezraklein is an apologist of white supremacist views and an accessory to genocidal state violence. https://t.co/e62YCWskYO

Matthew Yglesias @mattyglesias January 31, 2026

When Matthew Yglesias has to publicly defend his former colleague against accusations of white supremacy, something has gone deeply wrong with progressive politics.

The Echo Chamber Problem

How does a platform reach unanimous consensus that one of America’s most famous liberals is actually right-wing? Jesse Singal described Bluesky as "much more hermetically sealed from reality than Twitter.”

Under 700,000 unique daily posters makes Bluesky small enough for ideological homogeneity to take hold completely. When the only voices you hear call centrists “fascists,” your political compass breaks entirely. People do this to me all the time—center-left voices get labeled “right-wing” simply for not being extreme enough.

Disruption Isn’t Dialogue

The protesters didn’t want conversation—they wanted to shut down speech entirely.

Archived tweet

most telling part of this is that Ezra actually tries to talk to the protester and engage him, and he just turns around and keeps yelling at the audience. pretty clear example of how the heckler’s veto harms everyone else by prioritizing the needs of the heckler above the crowd https://t.co/ol4Y8AR5ZF

Armand Domalewski @ArmandDoma January 31, 2026

Klein actually tried to engage with the protester. The protester turned away and kept yelling at the audience. This is the tell: the heckler’s veto isn’t about communication. It’s about disruption. It takes time away from students who actually wanted to ask questions and engage with ideas.

If you can’t have a dialogue with Ezra Klein—someone who has spent his career engaging thoughtfully with policy—you can’t engage with anyone. You’ve declared that the entire liberal mainstream is the enemy.

If you really want to fight Trump, Democrats must be competent instead of clout-chasing extremists. When the left spends its energy attacking its own most effective voices—the people who actually know how to persuade swing voters and build coalitions—it guarantees its own irrelevance. The purity spiral doesn’t just hurt Klein. It dooms the causes these protesters claim to care about. You cannot win elections by calling everyone to your right a Nazi.

Follow @garrytan for more.